SET 03 · Membership (∈) vs Inclusion (⊆)
The single most tested distinction in this chapter
- — x is one of the items you see when you open box A.
- — X is a set, and each item of X is one of the items in box A.
The box analogy
. Open box A and you see 4 items: a smaller box , and 3, 4, 5. You do not see 1 or 2 — they’re inside the inner box.
- ? ❌ — 1 is inside the inner box, not a direct item of A.
- ? ✅ — the inner box is an item.
Recipe for any ∈ / ⊆ question
∈ question ”?” → Is X literally one of A’s listed items (as a whole)? ⊆ question ”?” → For each element x of X, ask ”?“. All yes ⇒ ⊆. If X isn’t a set (like the number 1), "" is simply false/ill-formed.
Practice on the slide’s sets
,
👁 Show answer
True — 1 is listed in B.
👁 Show answer
False — A’s items are {1,2}, 3, 4, 5. 1 is only inside {1,2}.
👁 Show answer
True — {1,2} is an item of A.
👁 Show answer
True — 3 ∈ A ✓, 4 ∈ A ✓.
👁 Show answer
False — 1 ∈ B ✓ but 6 ∉ B ✗.
👁 Show answer
False — 1 is not a set, so it can’t be a subset.
👁 Show answer
False — 1 ∉ A and 2 ∉ A. (Compare with Q3: {1,2} is an element of A, not a subset.)
👁 Show answer
True — its only element is {1,2}, and {1,2} ∈ A.
👁 Show answer
True — it’s equal to A, and .
Pattern from Q3, Q7, Q8
. Wrapping an element in braces turns ∈ into ⊆.
Solved problem (slides)
, . True or false?
a)
👁 Show answer
False — S contains a, not {a}.
b)
👁 Show answer
True — {a} is listed in R.
c)
👁 Show answer
True — a ∈ S ✓, 4 ∈ S ✓, {3} ∈ S ✓.
d)
👁 Show answer
False — the set equals R, so it’s a subset but not a proper subset.
e)
👁 Show answer
False — e.g. 2 ∈ S but 2 ∉ R (also a, {3} ∈ S but not in R).
f)
👁 Show answer
True — a ∈ S.
g)
👁 Show answer
False — a ∉ R (R has {a}, not a).
Prev ← SET 02 Subsets and Equality · Next → SET 04 Universal Null Singleton